Our verdict on Cadillac keeping Bottas over Herta for F1 2027
Cadillac has ended the uncertainty over Valtteri Bottas’s Formula 1 future by committing to him for 2027, despite having made sure Colton Herta qualified for an F1 superlicence.
Here’s our take on the decision.
Forget the performance gap, Bottas has value
Edd Straw
It's important to remember the reasons Bottas was signed in the first place. He brings experience, good cohesion with team-mate Sergio Perez and acts as an important building block for a squad that is still not a fully-formed F1 team and in its building-up process.
The complexity of F1 teams is enormous and invisible from the outside. That's why Bottas's contribution is measured by far more than his performances relative to Perez.
Perez has been the more impressive Cadillac driver this season on track, there's no doubt about that. However, often a fair comparison has been impossible given differences between the cars and the objectives. Bottas is a team player and has been doing the job asked of him.
I can understand why people find it a boring choice, and I'd be fascinated to see how Herta fares in a race seat, but the decision should be made on what the drivers bring to the team.
And right now, it's that invisible contribution that makes Bottas a more pragmatic option than a rookie - no matter how interesting the alternative might be.
No need to risk Herta now
Ben Anderson
The sensible and correct thing to do.
Not only would it have been needlessly expensive to ditch Bottas at this point, the upside of promoting Herta now - beyond the fact he's an American driver - just isn't there, as far as I can see.
While Cadillac remains a team rooted to the back of the grid, in need of experience to drive it forward, Herta risks getting swallowed up by that.
This way, Herta banks his F1 superlicence and gets more time to prepare himself for a future race seat, while the team continues milking Bottas for his vast nous and experience.
The fact Cadillac has Perez signed up to a new multi-year deal, while Bottas is only confirmed for 2027, tells you clearly the direction of travel, but it still makes sense not to pull that trigger too early.
Herta didn't build unstoppable momentum
Jack Benyon
Right when Herta was first seriously linked to replacing Bottas at Cadillac, in October, there were plenty of people suggesting that his F2 form was irrelevant and that other drivers prove it. But that only told half the story.
Yes, the likes of Ollie Bearman and Kimi Antonelli managed to graduate to F1 with relatively poor results, although for Antonelli, jumping from a Formula Regional car to an F2 car was a bit like going from the captain of a rubber dinghy to the commander in charge of an aircraft carrier.
The reason both of those drivers succeeded in F1 where they'd 'failed' in F2, is that both of them convinced very big teams that they were capable of racing in F1, regardless of underwhelming F2 form.
Whatever Cadillac's reasoning for sticking with Bottas, Herta hasn't quite made the same impression to make him undeniable for 2027, even though the paperwork now exists to make that a possibility.
He still has a chance to make it. Admittedly, given the poor F2 results and Cadillac opting for a currently-underwhelming Bottas over him, things don't look great.
But this also might just be Cadillac buying a bit more time for Herta.
That does mean he's likely to be 28 by the time he has a chance at a full-time F1 seat. That would feel very '1990s' and I'm here for it.
And it would be nice for him to get the chance to impress in practice shots in a more sorted Cadillac next year, where he can do a bit more performance running to show off his talent, rather than just the baseline work this new team needed in 2026.
Was 2028 always the Herta plan?
Scott Mitchell-Malm
This could be too influenced by hindsight, now that Cadillac has stuck with Bottas, but I do wonder if Herta/2027 was ever the play – and if it's really about weighing up whether he's the next guy in 2028.
Herta's superlicence saga is well documented and spans several seasons. I remember first writing about it during the 2021 Turkish Grand Prix weekend and chasing it in the Istanbul paddock!
A funny thing about the F1 superlicence is it's very hard to get but once you have it, it's easy to keep getting one even when you're not an active F1 driver.
So, given the hurdles and hoops Herta's been jumping over and running through, it stands to reason that Cadillac thought it was now or never to get the superlicence, knowing it extended the window to put him in the car. It could have been 2027, sure, but could be the years after.
And right now it doesn't look like there's a stunning case to put Herta in on performance alone. So, honour Bottas's deal, and the reasons he was signed - and prepare and assess Herta properly for 2028 knowing that there's not a regulatory nonsense to overcome to put him in the car. It'll just be about whether he's good enough.